Coldplay 被告抄歌事件

近來有很多 pop culture 法庭案,其中一單是 Coldplay 被告在新專輯 Viva La Vida 中的同名歌曲是抄自 Santriani 於2005年發表的結他 instrumental If I Could Fly,以下Video分別為兩首作品的對照:
如果你有時間想聽畢兩首作品的原裝版本,就看以下兩個 videos:

Coldplay Viva La Vida


Santriani If I Could Fly


如果你還有更多時間,不妨看看以下 Video ,這位先生用運樂理來解構與對比兩首歌曲了。


我對抄歌事件不予置評,只想說:

唉你知不知道我只喜歡Coldplay 一張大碟,唯一一張不是聽了幾次就覺得煩的 Viva La Vida。

15 comments:

manho said...

不嬲都好唔鍾意Coldplay
抄唔抄歌都唔影響我對呢隊band既感覺

losing loser said...

一出道就已經抽 radiohead 水架啦,thom york 都未出聲.

Jan said...

管他抄不抄,
反正歌出來是好聽!

Chi Yuen Lam said...

This Mr. Watson's analysis is amazing. Coldplay is in big trouble. Thanks Wan Chi!

另一值得思考問題,點解告抄襲永遠是不出名的告有免氣的?

Chi Yuen Lam said...

另一值得思考問題,點解告抄襲永遠是不出名的告有名氣的?

shoegazer said...

joe satriani is more famous...
he's been around since 80s

LJAMES said...

其實, Joe satriani 是非常非常出名的。在地球上少數的結他頂尖高手中,他是其中一個。

losing loser said...

LJAMES,讚!
就算你響旺角隨機問個路人甲,都未必聽過 jimi hendrix.
有時,紅真係無端端,無常理可言.

JY said...

To:Chi Yuen Lam
Joe Satriani 係一個非常出名的結他創作人,只不過同Coldplay 唔同聽眾層面!所以如果Coldplay真係抄Satriani,咁真係好唔聰明

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Interesting......
found this on youtube.....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLt_Hu8bHFc&feature=related

花蓮民宿 said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
花蓮民宿 said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Chi Yuen Lam said...
另一值得思考問題,點解告抄襲永遠是不出名的告有名氣的?

排除係咪真係被抄, 因為咁可以出名!

Anonymous said...

咁阿芝你姐係鐘意COLDPLAY邊張大碟?我其實幾鐘意X&Y.